Home   ::    Eatery   ::   Mail Order Pies   ::   In House Menu   ::   Fundraiser Program
Snapshots    ::   Pies & Sweet Things   ::   Events & Catering  ::   Contact Us  ::   Email Sign Up

Pies
All pies below are sold whole
or by the slice

9" pies
Shelf Pies $16.99 to $20.00
Cream Pies $18.99

6" pies :: $8.99

Pie by the Slice :: $4.95
served with ice cream and/or
whip cream

• Vanishing Blueberry
• Bumbleberry
• Vanishing Cherry
• Buttermilk
• Buttermilk Coconut
• Chocolate Peanut Butter
• Chocolate Silk
• Chocolate Cream
• Coconut Cream
• Lemon Cream
• Key Lime
• Mississippi Mud
• No Sugar Added Apple
• No Sugar Added Cherry
• No Sugar Added Peach
• Southern Pecan
• Pumpkin (seasonal)
• Apple Streusel
• Peach Streusel
• Cherry Streusel
• Sour Cream Raisin
• Strawberry Rhubarb

Special Order pies:: $19.99

• Strawberry Cream
• Banana Cream
• Chocolate Meringue
• Coconut Meringue
• Lemon Meringue
• Sweet Potato

Pie in the Sky Pie Co. only uses the freshest
ingredients available and makes our pies from
scratch every day. Come in to either of our two
locations and have a slice or buy one or two
whole pies, if you can’t make it in buy some
at the online “Pie Shop” and we will mail it
to you fresh as can be.

If you have a favorite and we do not have it in
our line up let us know!

To place an order please call us at
(Conroe) 936-760-3301
(24 hr notice is needed for most orders except for Holidays).

Cake Balls, Sweet Breads,
Chess Bars & Brownies

Sweet Breads :: $6.50 per loaf

• Banana Bread
• Cranberry Orange Bread
• San Francisco Lemon Bread
• Blueberry Crumb Loaf

Cake Balls :: $1.79 each

• Italian Cream
• Chocolate
• Red Velet
• Chocolate Peanut Butter

Fudge Brownies & Chess Bars :: $2.49 each

*Assorted pastries vary in price